Covered Call Assignment – How To Avoid It & What To Do If Assigned

Imagine you have a Covered Call right now and the underlying stock is now above your Covered Call strike price.

You’re panicking now because if you get assigned on the Covered Call, you will be Short 100 shares.

The worst part is that you don’t have the necessary capital to meet the margin requirement of Shorting the 100 shares.

And that would result in a margin call.

So what do you do?

And how do you avoid getting the risk of early assignment on your Covered Call?

What Happens When You’re Assigned On Your Covered Call?

Let’s assume you already own 100 shares of Amazon (Ticker: AMZN).

Then you sell a Covered Call at the strike price of 135.

If AMZN settles anywhere above $135 at the expiration date of the Covered Call, then your 100 shares will be called away at that price.

That means your 100 shares would be sold at $135.

When Are You In Danger Of Early Assignment?

So when is your Covered Call in danger of getting assigned early?

There’s always the possibility of early assignment when:

• Your Covered Call is In-The-Money (ITM). That means the current stock price is above your Covered Call strike price.
• And when your Covered Call is close to expiration.
• And when your extrinsic value is very little.
• And if the stock pays a dividend, you could get assigned early if the dividend paid is more than the extrinsic value.

In short, the main factor that determines whether you are in danger of getting assigned early is when the extrinsic value is very little.

That’s because when there’s little extrinsic value left in your Covered Call, there’s not much incentive left for the buyer to hold on to the Call Option.

So it’s very important to pay attention to how much extrinsic value is left in your Covered Call.

The good news is that getting assigned early is actually very rare.

To understand a little better why this is so, we need to get into the minds of the Call buyer (the person taking the opposite trade of your Covered Call).

Understanding The Mindset of Call Buyers

For this, let’s use the same example as we did earlier.

And let’s also assume that for selling the 135 strike price Covered Call you received a premium of $1.50.

Now let’s switch sides and imagine you’re now the Call buyer that just purchased the Call Option for $1.50.

Next, we want to come up with the different scenarios that might happen and see if you would exercise your Call Option early for each of them.

Scenario 1: Stock goes to $140.

In this scenario, the stock has gone up to $140 and your Call Option has now increased to $6.00:

• $5.00 in intrinsic value.
• $1.00 in extrinsic value.

By exercising your Call Option, you would be buying 100 shares of the underlying stock at $135.

And you will forfeit your extrinsic value of $1.00.

Knowing this, would you exercise your Call Option?

Let’s compare exercising versus selling off your Call Option.

If you exercise and you sell off your shares immediately after exercising, your profits would be:

[($140 – $135) x 100 shares] – $150 for purchasing the Call Option = $350

If you just sold off your Call Option, your profits would be:

($6.00 – $1.50) x 100 shares = $450

As you can see, you would have made more money if you had simply sold off your Call Option.

That’s because the extrinsic value boosted your profits.

But if you exercised your Call Option, you forfeited the extra $100 in profits.

Furthermore, exercising can come with extra fees from some brokers.

So in this scenario, it’s highly unlikely that the Call Buyer would exercise their Call Option, even if it’s ITM.

Scenario 2: Stock goes to $150.

Now what if the stock went higher to $150 instead?

In this scenario, your Call Option is now worth $15.25:

• $15.00 in intrinsic value.
• $0.25 in extrinsic value.

If you are the Call Buyer, would you exercise your Call Option now?

If you do, you’d be giving up $0.25 in extrinsic value.

That’s $25 in additional profits that you would miss out on by exercising.

I’m pretty sure it’s unlikely that you would exercise because I wouldn’t as well.

While $25 may not be much, it’s still money that we leave on the table by exercising.

So it makes no sense for us to exercise the Call Option and get into a Long stock when there’s still lots of time left before expiration.

If we really wanted to buy the stock, we still can wait till the last few days to expiration before deciding whether to exercise the Long Call or not.

So as you can see, extrinsic value plays a big part in the Call buyer’s decision whether to exercise the Call Option or not.

Scenario 3: Stock goes to $140 but goes ex-dividend tomorrow paying a dividend of $0.50.

This scenario is similar to scenario 1, but the difference is that the stock will be paying a dividend.

This is where a Short Call can have dividend risk.

That means that the Call buyer may want to exercise their Option to get into a Long stock position to get the dividends.

So in this scenario, your Call Option’s value is the same as scenario 1 which is $6.00:

• $5.00 in intrinsic value.
• $1.00 in extrinsic value.

However, the underlying stock will be paying a dividend of $0.50.

If you’re the Call buyer, would you exercise your Long Call?

Let’s compare exercising versus selling the Call Option.

If you exercise it, you will forfeit the $1.00 in extrinsic value, but gain the dividend of $0.50.

But if you sell the Call Option, you will forfeit the $0.50 dividend, but profit on the $1.00 in extrinsic value.

So in this scenario, you would gain more by simply selling the Call Option.

Hence, it’s for the Covered Call to get assigned in this scenario.

Scenario 4: Stock goes to $150 but goes ex-dividend tomorrow paying a dividend of $0.50.

This scenario is similar to scenario 2 but the stock goes ex-dividend tomorrow with a dividend payout of $0.50.

In this scenario, your Call Option’s value is $15.25:

• $15.00 in intrinsic value.
• $0.25 in extrinsic value.

But there’s a dividend payout of $0.50.

In this scenario, if you were the Call buyer, would you exercise your Long Call?

If we applied the same analysis as in scenario 3, then we would know that it makes sense to exercise the Call Option now because the dividend is greater than the extrinsic value.

That means by exercising the Call Option, you’d gain an additional $0.25 compared to if you hadn’t exercised your Long Call.

So in this scenario, there’s a high likelihood of getting assigned early.

How To Avoid Early Assignment

So how do you avoid the risk of early assignment?

By rolling your Covered Call.

When you roll, you’re adding duration to your Covered Call.

And by adding duration, you’re adding extrinsic value.

Remember, extrinsic value is simply time value.

The more days left to expiration, the more extrinsic value there is.

Additionally, when rolling, you have the choice to roll your Covered Call up as well.

That means you roll to a higher strike on top of rolling to a further expiration date.

This way you increase the chances of Covered Call working out.

But what if you’re already assigned?

If you’re already assigned and your shares have been called away, there are 3 things you can do:

• Buy back the stock. If you’re confident the stock will still go up in the long run, then you can always buy back your shares. There are two ways to do this:
  1. Buy your shares back immediately if you’re afraid the stock will continue rallying.
  2. Wait for a pullback before buying again.
• Sell a Cash Secured Put at the price you were called away.
• Find other trades.

At the end of the day, having your shares called away isn’t the end of the world.

You’ve already made a profit (assuming your Covered Call was above your entry price), and you can always find another trade.

And if you think the stock will keep going up in the long term, then just buy back the stock because you would still be in profit if you’re right on your long-term view.